Buddy's attempt to outfox the detectives backfires; Dora, Alexa and Russell suspect something ominous is going on with their new pastor; Schmidt learns the truth about Ashlee.
The church must convince an eccentric elderly woman to donate her estate; Dora goes on a date with Detective Lovello; Schmidt makes a troubling confession.
An ex-con threatens to burn down the church; Dora's relationship with Detective Lovello proves dangerous; Russell helps Schmidt set up his new bachelor pad.
Buddy falls into a deadly criminal's trap; the church council unites to stop an arson attempt on Ladner Trinity; Dora reconnects with her high school crush.
Buddy must choose to save Dora or Alexa when both are in danger; Russell and Dora have a falling out; Schmidt is robbed.
Bishop Perkins returns with an announcement that rocks Trinity Lutheran; Sheriff Graham turns up the heat on Buddy regarding a recent murder in town; Alexa reveals an astonishing secret.
Russell calls on Buddy to become more of a leader in the gay community; Sheriff Graham enlists Dora to spy on Buddy and Alexa; Schmidt and Ashlee take their relationship public.
Buddy's attempt to counsel Russell's little brother goes awry; Dora decides to run against Schmidt for church president; Buddy struggles with his feelings for Alexa.
The FBI has a surprise plan for Buddy; Sheriff Graham finally drops the hammer on the pastor; Dora suspects Buddy has a female lover.
Buddy deals with the arrival of Alexa's husband; Dora makes a frightening discovery; Schmidt's engagement party takes an unexpected turn.