As the summer comes to an end, Felicity's father begins nagging her about her future.
Felicity feels extremely guilty after having sex with Noel. She seeks Dr. Pavone's advice on whether she should tell Ben.
Ben and Felicity get back together. She confesses her fling with Noel to Javier, who promises to keep quiet.
Javier helps Felicity prepare for the beauty pageant. She befriends an aspiring singer but has several run-ins with a rude contestant named Denise.
Ben and Trevor fail their organic chemistry midterm and ask for a chance to retake the test. Ben insults the professor after he belittles them.
Ben learns that his father is being hospitalized with liver failure. Mr. Covington gives Ben power of attorney.
Ben refuses to talk to Felicity and will only go near her to retrieve his belongings.
Meghan tells Felicity that she has concocted a spell to reunite her with Ben.
Ben defends Felicity against a rude customer at Dean & DeLuca. Felicity invites Ben to come over to the apartment to talk.
Ben focuses all of his attention on studying as he prepares for his organic chemistry final.
Felicity is confused when Ben begins dropping by her apartment frequently. However, he is not ready to get back together.
As the spring semester begins, Lauren tells Ben that she is pregnant, and that he is the father.
Mr. Covington learns of Lauren's pregnancy and criticizes the absentee father, unaware that it is Ben.
Ben decides that he wants to play an active role in his child's life. Lauren is pleased but has already made arrangements to move to Arizona.
Felicity worries that Ben is drifting away after she observes his reaction to a sonogram of his son.
Lauren comes by Dean & DeLuca to announce that she is leaving the next day and expects Ben to help her move.
Felicity is able to graduate because Professor Carnes fails her on the paper but lets her pass the class.
Felicity becomes distant and withdrawn after Elena dies in a car accident. She pulls away from Ben.
Felicity and Noel decide to stay away from their usual date locations so that they can avoid Ben.
Ben questions Felicity's relationship with Noel and confidently predicts that she will soon try to win back Ben.
Felicity tries to convince Noel that she wants to be with him. She finally tells him that she traveled through time for him.
Felicity blames herself for Noel's death because he had survived the fire in the original history.