Marius returns to the farm in hopes of finding a deeper connection with the Bernhardts, but his past soon catches up and tempts him back into the con life; Julia finds herself holding a big secret while serious legal issues put her life in jeopardy.
Marius falls back in with a dangerous con woman named Lizzie; fired by Audrey, Julia searches for new employment; Audrey and Otto scramble to save their business; Carly's continued probing about her parents' death has emotional ramifications.
Marius must split focus from his con with Lizzie in order to help Julia with a con of her own; Otto enlists Taylor to assist in helping a friend named Lorraine rescue her daughter; Carly uncovers a family secret that leads her out to California.
Marius and Julia travel to Vermont to enlist a reluctant art forger out of retirement; Taylor is suspended from the police force and seeks solace with Lorraine; in California, Audrey faces her estranged father as she agrees to help Carly.
Marius and Julia's con takes them out to California; Audrey and Carly follow multiple leads in their search for answers about Lila's location; back in Bridgeport, Lizzie entangles herself in the Bernhardt family business to keep Marius under control.
Audrey enlists Marius' help in the search for Lila; they soon discover that her life was far more complicated than they ever expected; simmering conflict over Lorraine comes out into the open as Otto and Taylor set out on a cross-country trip.
In the wake of nearly connecting with Lila, the family struggles to come to terms with the idea that she may be alive and in serious danger; Audrey and Otto become unwitting participants in both of Marius' cons.
Julia gets kidnapped, and Marius must determine his loyalties as he struggles to keep both cons in motion; the family must figure out a plan to save Julia, but they quickly realize the situation is more complicated and dangerous than they expected.
Marius must overcome a change in Lizzie's allegiance and maintain the trust of the Bernhardts; as Taylor and Otto work in earnest to rescue Julia, they find a way to overcome their disagreements; secrets are revealed; the family may learn the truth.
Marius and the Bernhardts take part in a con to free Julia; Marius and Lizzie square off as Juia's life is in the balance.